Finding Permutiples: A Graph Theory and Finite-State Machine Approach

Core Concepts

This paper presents two novel methods for systematically finding permutiples – numbers that are multiples of permutations of their own digits – leveraging graph theory and finite-state machine constructions.

Abstract

• Bibliographic Information: Holt, B.V. (2024). Finding Permutiples of a Known Base and Multiplier. arXiv:2411.10859v1 [math.CO]

• Research Objective: This paper aims to develop methods for finding permutiples of a given base and multiplier without relying on prior known examples or specific digit knowledge.

• Methodology: The research employs two primary approaches:

  1. Graph-Theoretical Approach: Introduces the concept of "permutiple graphs" to represent the relationship between digits and their permutations in a permutiple. Analyzes the properties of these graphs, particularly cycles, to identify potential permutiples.
  2. Finite-State Machine Approach: Adapts Hoey-Sloane machines, typically used for recognizing palindromes, to create a finite-state machine that recognizes permutiple strings. This method utilizes the carries generated during single-digit multiplication to define state transitions.

• Key Findings:

  • Permutiple graphs exhibit specific structural characteristics, being composed of cycles within a larger "mother graph."
  • The cycles within the mother graph provide a basis for constructing potential permutiple candidates.
  • Finite-state machines, specifically adapted Hoey-Sloane machines, offer an effective way to model and identify permutiple strings.

• Main Conclusions:

  • The graph-theoretical and finite-state machine methods provide powerful tools for systematically discovering permutiples.
  • These methods eliminate the need for prior knowledge of specific examples or digit arrangements, enabling a more comprehensive search.

• Significance: This research significantly advances the understanding and identification of permutiples, a topic of interest in recreational mathematics and number theory. The systematic approaches presented offer new avenues for exploring the properties and distribution of these unique numbers.

• Limitations and Future Research: The paper primarily focuses on finding permutiples up to a known length. Further research could explore extending these methods to identify permutiples of arbitrary length or with specific characteristics. Additionally, investigating the computational complexity of these algorithms and potential optimizations could be valuable.

Stats

Quotes

Key Insights Distilled From

Finding Permutiples of a Known Base and Multiplier

by Benjamin V. ... at arxiv.org 11-19-2024

https://arxiv.org/pdf/2411.10859.pdf

Deeper Inquiries

How can these methods be adapted to explore permutiple-like properties in other mathematical structures or sequences?

The methods described in the paper rely on several key concepts that can be potentially generalized to other mathematical structures:

Digit-preserving operations: The core idea of a permutiple is a number that maintains a specific relationship (multiplication in this case) with a permutation of its digits. This can be extended to other operations beyond multiplication, such as addition, subtraction, exponentiation, or even modular arithmetic. For example, one could explore "additive permutiples" where a number is the sum of a permutation of its digits.
Base representation: The paper focuses on numbers represented in a positional base system. This concept can be broadened to other representations, such as continued fractions, factorial number systems, or even representations based on specific sequences like Fibonacci numbers. The challenge lies in defining appropriate digit permutation and arithmetic operations within these systems.
Graph representation: The use of graphs, particularly the mother graph and the Hoey-Sloane graph, provides a visual and structural understanding of permutiple properties. This approach can be adapted to other structures by defining appropriate vertices and edges based on the relationships and operations relevant to the specific mathematical structure under consideration. For example, in a group-theoretic context, vertices could represent group elements, and edges could represent the group operation.
Examples of adaptations:

Permutations of prime factors: Instead of digits, one could investigate numbers that are multiples of a permutation of their prime factors. This would require adapting the concept of base representation and defining appropriate operations on prime factorizations.
Permutiple-like properties in polynomials: The concept of digit permutation can be extended to the coefficients of polynomials. One could explore polynomials that maintain a specific relationship with a permutation of their coefficients under operations like differentiation, integration, or polynomial multiplication.

Could there be limitations to these methods, particularly when dealing with very large bases or multipliers, and how might those limitations be addressed?

Yes, the methods presented face limitations with increasing base and multiplier size:

Computational complexity: Constructing the mother graph and the Hoey-Sloane graph, as well as searching for strongly connected components, can become computationally expensive for large bases and multipliers. The number of vertices and edges in these graphs grows rapidly, making computations and storage demanding.
Combinatorial explosion: As the base and multiplier increase, the number of possible digit combinations and permutations grows exponentially. This leads to a combinatorial explosion, making it challenging to exhaustively search for permutiples within a reasonable time frame.
Addressing the limitations:

Algorithmic optimization: Developing more efficient algorithms for graph construction, cycle detection, and strongly connected component identification could help mitigate the computational burden.
Exploiting symmetries and patterns: Permutiple properties often exhibit symmetries and patterns that can be exploited to reduce the search space. Identifying and utilizing these patterns can significantly improve efficiency.
Probabilistic and heuristic approaches: Instead of exhaustive searches, employing probabilistic methods like random sampling or using heuristics based on observed patterns could provide approximate solutions or identify promising regions of the search space.
Parallel and distributed computing: Leveraging the power of parallel and distributed computing can help tackle the computational challenges posed by large bases and multipliers. Distributing the workload across multiple processors or computers can significantly reduce computation time.

If we view permutiple generation as a form of pattern creation, what are the implications for understanding pattern formation in other domains, such as art, music, or natural phenomena?

Viewing permutiple generation as pattern creation offers intriguing connections to other domains:

Underlying rules and constraints: Permutiples arise from specific mathematical rules and constraints (base representation, digit permutation, arithmetic operations). Similarly, patterns in art, music, and nature often emerge from underlying principles and limitations. Understanding these underlying rules can provide insights into the generative processes behind these patterns.
Iteration and recursion: The methods for finding permutiples involve iterative processes and recursive structures (cycles in graphs, repeated application of rules). These concepts are also fundamental to pattern formation in various domains. For example, fractals in nature often exhibit self-similarity and recursive patterns.
Emergence and complexity: Simple rules governing permutiple generation can lead to surprisingly complex and intricate patterns. This highlights the concept of emergence, where complex behavior arises from the interaction of simpler components. This principle is observed in various natural phenomena, such as the intricate patterns in snowflakes or the flocking behavior of birds.
Implications:

Cross-disciplinary inspiration: The study of permutiples and their generation can inspire new approaches to understanding and creating patterns in other fields. For instance, the use of graph theory and finite-state machines could be adapted to analyze and generate musical melodies or visual patterns.
Unifying framework: Recognizing the shared principles of pattern formation across different domains can contribute to a more unified understanding of complexity and emergence. This can lead to new insights and connections between seemingly disparate fields.
Computational creativity: The methods used to generate permutiples can be seen as a form of computational creativity, where algorithms are used to explore and generate novel patterns. This has implications for developing artificial intelligence systems capable of artistic expression and creative problem-solving.