Core Concepts

Annealed Importance Sampling (AIS) can be significantly improved for estimating the partition function of Restricted Boltzmann Machines by using a properly selected mean-field starting probability distribution.

Abstract

The authors present a systematic analysis of using Annealed Importance Sampling (AIS) to efficiently estimate the partition function of Restricted Boltzmann Machines (RBMs). They show that the quality of the estimation and the computational cost can be significantly improved by using a properly selected mean-field starting probability distribution, compared to the standard approach of starting from the uniform probability distribution.
The key highlights are:
The authors derive the optimal mean-field starting probability distribution that minimizes the Kullback-Leibler divergence to the actual RBM probability distribution.
They propose two successful strategies, Pseudoinverse (Pinv) and Signs from Random Hidden (Signs h), to approximate the optimal mean-field distribution when the exact averages are not computable.
The authors test their approaches on various datasets, including artificially generated weights, RBM learning weights, and magnetic spin systems. They show that the proposed strategies outperform the standard approach of starting from the uniform distribution.
For a large-scale RBM with 500 hidden units on the MNIST dataset, the authors demonstrate that their methods provide estimations of the partition function that are in excellent agreement with state-of-the-art procedures, while being computationally more efficient.
The authors conclude that the proposed strategies are good starting points to estimate the partition function with AIS with a relatively low computational cost, and can be used as a basis for further studies on partition function estimation in RBMs.

Stats

The partition function Z is defined as the sum over all possible states x of the Boltzmann factor e^(-E(x)/T), where E(x) is the energy of state x and T is the temperature.
The evaluation of the partition function Z is known to be an NP-hard problem.

Quotes

"The relevance but unfortunate computational complexity implied in the determination of Z has raised the urge to devise methods to approximate it in a tractable way."
"Surprisingly, and despite its broad formulation in terms of an initial and a final probability distributions, little use has been seen of the AIS algorithm in the numerical simulation of physical systems to the best of our knowledge."

Deeper Inquiries

The proposed strategies for estimating the optimal mean field starting point for Annealed Importance Sampling can be extended to various types of probabilistic models beyond Restricted Boltzmann Machines. These strategies rely on approximating the optimal mean field distribution by leveraging the relationship between the visible units and the hidden units in the model. This approach can be applied to other models that exhibit similar dependencies between variables. For instance, in models with different architectures or interactions, one can adapt the strategies by considering the specific relationships between variables and deriving approximations for the optimal mean field distribution based on those relationships. By understanding the underlying structure of the model and the interactions between variables, similar strategies can be developed to improve the efficiency and accuracy of partition function estimation using Annealed Importance Sampling.

The theoretical limits of accuracy that can be achieved using mean-field approximations as the starting point for Annealed Importance Sampling are influenced by several factors. While mean-field approximations provide a computationally efficient way to estimate the partition function of complex systems, they are inherently approximate and may not capture all the nuances of the true distribution. The accuracy of the mean-field approximation depends on the degree of correlation between variables in the model and the complexity of the interactions. In cases where the mean-field approximation closely matches the true distribution, the accuracy of the estimation can be high. However, as the system becomes more intricate or the interactions between variables become stronger, the accuracy of the mean-field approximation may decrease. The theoretical limits of accuracy are ultimately determined by the fidelity of the mean-field approximation to the true distribution and the ability of Annealed Importance Sampling to correct for any discrepancies.

The insights from this work can be applied to improve the efficiency of other Monte Carlo sampling techniques used for partition function estimation. By utilizing optimal mean-field approximations as the starting point for sampling, researchers can enhance the efficiency and accuracy of Monte Carlo methods in estimating partition functions for various probabilistic models. The strategies developed in this study, such as the Pseudoinverse and Signs from Random Hidden approaches, can be adapted and integrated into different Monte Carlo sampling techniques to enhance their performance. By incorporating these insights, researchers can optimize the initial sampling distributions and improve the overall efficiency of partition function estimation using Monte Carlo methods.

0