The content discusses the significant reproducibility challenges in the field of 2D materials research and provides a multi-stakeholder approach to address this issue.
Key highlights:
The 2D materials research field has experienced rapid progress, but this has been accompanied by a concerning lack of reproducibility in many studies. This "reproducibility gap" hinders the field's scientific maturation and technological development.
The authors outline recommendations for researchers at different stages of the research process, including funding, planning, execution, reporting, peer review, citation, and follow-up. These recommendations cover topics such as detailed methodology documentation, transparent data sharing, and engaging in replication efforts.
The Standardized Template for Experimental Procedures (STEP) is introduced as a framework to facilitate comprehensive and structured reporting of experimental details, enabling easier replication by other researchers.
The ReChart system is proposed as a way for researchers to declare their adherence to various reproducibility targets, providing a consistent reference for authors, reviewers, and readers.
The authors also provide targeted recommendations for other key stakeholders, including funding bodies, publishers, peer reviewers, industry, policymakers, and educational institutions, to foster a culture of transparency and reliability in 2D materials research.
Addressing the reproducibility crisis in 2D materials research requires a collaborative effort involving all stakeholders to improve research practices, data management, and the overall research ecosystem.
To Another Language
from source content
arxiv.org
Deeper Inquiries