Efficient Online Estimation via Offline Estimation: An Information-Theoretic Framework

Core Concepts

It is possible to achieve near-optimal online estimation error by converting offline estimation algorithms into online estimation algorithms in a black-box fashion, up to logarithmic factors.

Abstract

The paper introduces a new framework called Oracle-Efficient Online Estimation (OEOE), where the learner can only interact with the data stream indirectly through a sequence of offline estimators produced by a black-box algorithm.
The key results are:

Statistical complexity:

For finite classes F, there exists an oracle-efficient algorithm that achieves near-optimal online estimation error, up to a logarithmic factor (Theorem 3.1). This is shown to be nearly tight (Theorem 3.2).
For memoryless oracle-efficient algorithms, strong impossibility results are shown (Theorem 3.3).
A general reduction from oracle-efficient online estimation to delayed online learning is provided (Theorem 3.4), and used to characterize oracle-efficient learnability for classification with infinite classes (Theorem 3.5).

Computational complexity:

Under standard complexity assumptions, there do not exist polynomial-time algorithms with non-trivial online estimation error in the OEOE framework (Theorem 4.1).
However, for conditional density estimation, online estimation in the OEOE framework is no harder computationally than online estimation with arbitrary, unrestricted algorithms (Theorem 4.2).

The results have implications for interactive decision making, showing that it is information-theoretically possible to achieve near-optimal regret for any interactive decision making problem using an algorithm that accesses the data stream only through offline estimation oracles (Corollary 5.1).

Stats

None.

Quotes

None.

Key Insights Distilled From

Online Estimation via Offline Estimation: An Information-Theoretic Framework

by Dylan J. Fos... at arxiv.org 04-17-2024

https://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10122.pdf

Deeper Inquiries

How can the techniques developed in this paper be extended to handle more complex function classes and loss functions beyond the canonical examples considered

The techniques developed in this paper can be extended to handle more complex function classes and loss functions by adapting the framework to accommodate the specific characteristics of these classes. For example, for function classes that are not finite, such as infinite classes or function spaces, the analysis can be extended by considering appropriate complexity measures like Rademacher complexity or Littlestone dimension. This would allow for a more nuanced understanding of the sample complexity and the performance of oracle-efficient algorithms in these settings.
Similarly, for loss functions beyond the canonical examples considered in the paper, such as non-convex or non-metric-like losses, the framework can be adapted to incorporate the specific properties of these loss functions. This may involve developing new algorithmic techniques or theoretical analyses tailored to the characteristics of the loss functions. By generalizing the framework to handle a broader range of function classes and loss functions, the insights and results obtained in this paper can be applied to a wider variety of estimation problems in machine learning and statistics.

What are the practical implications of the computational complexity results, and how can they guide the design of efficient algorithms for interactive decision making

The computational complexity results presented in the paper have important practical implications for the design of efficient algorithms for interactive decision making. The finding that there do not exist polynomial-time algorithms with non-trivial online estimation error in the OEOE framework under standard computational complexity conjectures highlights the inherent challenges in achieving efficient online estimation via black-box offline estimation oracles. This result suggests that, in practice, it may be necessary to strike a balance between computational efficiency and estimation accuracy when designing algorithms for interactive decision making.
The insights from the computational complexity results can guide the development of algorithmic techniques that prioritize computational efficiency without sacrificing estimation performance. For example, researchers and practitioners can explore approximation algorithms, heuristic methods, or algorithmic optimizations to improve the efficiency of online estimation algorithms within the constraints imposed by the computational complexity limitations. By leveraging these insights, algorithm designers can make informed decisions about the trade-offs between computational resources and estimation quality in the context of interactive decision making applications.

Are there other applications beyond interactive decision making where the OEOE framework and the insights from this paper could be useful

The OEOE framework and the insights from this paper could be useful in various applications beyond interactive decision making. One potential application is in online learning and sequential decision-making problems, where the framework's information-theoretic perspective on converting offline estimation algorithms into online estimation algorithms could provide valuable guidance for algorithm design. By leveraging the insights from the OEOE framework, researchers and practitioners can develop more efficient and effective online learning algorithms for a wide range of applications, including online recommendation systems, adaptive control systems, and online optimization problems.
Additionally, the OEOE framework could be applied in the context of active learning and experimental design, where the goal is to select informative data points for labeling or measurement to improve the learning process. By incorporating the principles of oracle-efficient online estimation, researchers can develop strategies for adaptive data selection and exploration that optimize the learning process while minimizing resource consumption. This could lead to more efficient and effective active learning algorithms that adaptively select data points for labeling based on the information provided by offline estimation oracles.