Efficient Algorithms for Folding Carpenter's Rulers into Rectangles

Core Concepts

The paper proposes the Ruler Rolling problem, a more realistic variant of the Ruler Folding and Ruler Wrapping problems, where a carpenter's ruler is folded into a rectangle using 90-degree folds in the same direction. The authors provide a quadratic-time algorithm to find all Pareto-optimal rollings under the assumption that the last segment extends strictly beyond every other.

Abstract

The paper introduces the Ruler Rolling problem, which is a more realistic variant of the previously studied Ruler Folding and Ruler Wrapping problems. In Ruler Rolling, the segments of a carpenter's ruler are folded 90 degrees in the same direction to form a rectangle, rather than being folded 180 degrees in alternating directions to form an interval. The key highlights and insights are: The authors show that if the last segment of the ruler must extend strictly beyond every other, then Ruler Rolling is equivalent to partitioning a string of positive integers into substrings such that the sums of the even substrings are increasing, and the sums of the odd substrings are increasing. They provide a simple online dynamic programming algorithm that reports all the Pareto-optimal rollings in quadratic time under this assumption. The algorithm works even without the assumption, but then it is not online and the number of feasible two-dimensional solutions is quadratic, so finding the Pareto-optimal ones and discarding the others increases the running time by a logarithmic factor. The authors discuss the challenges of dropping the simplifying assumption and suggest that finding a quadratic-time algorithm for Ruler Rolling with no assumptions at all is an open problem. They also mention that if a nice objective function is available, the running time can be kept quadratic, as the objective function can project all the solutions onto a line, and then the minimum can be found in time linear in the number of solutions and quadratic in the number of segments. The paper provides a proof of correctness for the proposed algorithm and discusses future work, including rolling rulers into triangles and handling cases where the folding direction can change.

Stats

None.

Quotes

None.

Key Insights Distilled From

Ruler Rolling

by Xing Lyu,Tra... at arxiv.org 04-08-2024

https://arxiv.org/pdf/2210.01954.pdf

Deeper Inquiries

What are some potential real-world applications of the Ruler Rolling problem beyond the carpenter's ruler scenario

The Ruler Rolling problem, beyond its application to carpenter's rulers, has potential real-world applications in various fields. One such application could be in the design and optimization of packaging solutions. Companies that need to efficiently pack products into boxes or containers could use the principles of Ruler Rolling to determine the optimal dimensions for packaging to minimize wasted space and reduce shipping costs. Additionally, in the field of urban planning, Ruler Rolling concepts could be applied to optimize the layout of city blocks or the allocation of land for different purposes, ensuring efficient use of space and resources.

How could the Ruler Rolling problem be extended to consider additional constraints, such as the maximum allowed height or width of the final rectangle

To extend the Ruler Rolling problem with additional constraints, such as the maximum allowed height or width of the final rectangle, the algorithm would need to be modified to consider these limitations during the rolling process. For example, the dynamic programming algorithm could be adapted to track and update the height and width of the rolling rectangle as it progresses, ensuring that the dimensions do not exceed the specified maximum values. This extension would add an extra layer of complexity to the problem, requiring careful consideration of how to balance the Pareto-optimal solutions with the new constraints.

Are there any connections between the Ruler Rolling problem and other well-studied problems in combinatorial optimization or computational geometry

The Ruler Rolling problem shares connections with other well-studied problems in combinatorial optimization and computational geometry. One such connection is with the classic Knapsack Problem, where items with given weights and values must be selected to maximize the total value without exceeding a weight constraint. In Ruler Rolling, the segments of the ruler can be seen as items with lengths and widths, and the rolling process is akin to selecting a subset of segments to fit within the constraints of the final rectangle. Additionally, the Longest Increasing Subsequence problem, which involves finding the longest subsequence of a given sequence that is in increasing order, bears similarities to the Ruler Rolling problem when considering the increasing sums of substrings in the ruler's segments. These connections highlight the interdisciplinary nature of optimization problems and the potential for cross-pollination of algorithms and techniques.