How Christian Publishing Promotes a Specific Notion of Masculinity Influenced by a Left-Wing Pagan Poet

Core Concepts

Christian publishing promotes a particular notion of masculinity that is influenced by a left-wing pagan poet, rather than inherent to the religion itself.

Abstract

The article discusses how the recent trend in Christian publishing of books aimed at helping men become more "masculine" is not rooted in traditional Christian teachings, but rather seems to be influenced by ideas from a left-wing pagan poet. The author notes that these books typically promote a vision of masculinity that is "right-wing, assertive, aggressive, dominant." However, the article questions where the Christian religion got this idea of masculinity, suggesting it may have been influenced by external sources rather than being inherent to the faith. The article implies that the Christian concept of masculinity being pushed in these popular books is not an authentic representation of traditional Christian values, but rather a commercialized version shaped by external cultural and political factors. It raises the possibility that Christians have learned this notion of masculinity from a left-wing pagan poet, rather than developing it organically within their own religious tradition.

Stats

None.

Quotes

None.

Key Insights Distilled From

Christians learned “masculinity” from a left-wing pagan poet

by Jonathan Pol... at medium.com 06-30-2024

https://medium.com/belover/christians-learned-masculinity-from-a-left-wing-pagan-poet-d775b8a77dac

Deeper Inquiries

What specific left-wing pagan poet is being referenced, and how did their ideas influence the Christian concept of masculinity?

The left-wing pagan poet being referenced in this context is likely to be Virgil, a Roman poet known for his epic poem, the Aeneid. Virgil's portrayal of masculinity in characters like Aeneas, who embodies qualities of strength, courage, and leadership, has had a significant influence on the Christian concept of masculinity. Early Christian thinkers, such as Augustine of Hippo, drew upon Virgil's works to shape their understanding of virtuous masculinity, incorporating elements of heroism and moral integrity into Christian ideals of manhood.

How do the masculine ideals promoted in these Christian books compare to the actual teachings and values found in the Bible and Christian tradition?

The masculine ideals promoted in many contemporary Christian books often emphasize traits like assertiveness, dominance, and aggression, which may not always align with the teachings and values found in the Bible and Christian tradition. While the Bible does contain examples of strong male figures like David and Joshua, it also emphasizes humility, compassion, and self-sacrifice as essential qualities of a godly man. Jesus Christ, as the ultimate example of masculinity in Christianity, exhibited characteristics of love, gentleness, and servant leadership, which may differ from the more aggressive and dominant portrayals often promoted in modern Christian literature.

What are the potential societal impacts of this commercialized, externally-influenced version of masculinity being propagated through Christian publishing?

The commercialized and externally-influenced version of masculinity being propagated through Christian publishing can have several societal impacts. Firstly, it may contribute to the reinforcement of harmful gender stereotypes and expectations, leading to rigid and unrealistic standards for men to conform to. This can result in feelings of inadequacy, pressure to perform, and a distorted view of masculinity that may not align with the diverse experiences and expressions of manhood. Additionally, by prioritizing certain traits over others, such as aggression over empathy or dominance over collaboration, this version of masculinity may hinder healthy relationships, emotional well-being, and personal growth for individuals seeking to live out their faith authentically. Ultimately, a more nuanced and holistic understanding of masculinity, rooted in the teachings of the Bible and Christian tradition, can help promote a healthier and more inclusive vision of manhood within both religious and secular contexts.