Sign In

Identifying the Origin Model of Generated Images Using Few-shot Examples

Core Concepts
This work proposes a CLIP-based framework, OCC-CLIP, to determine if a given image was generated by the same model as a set of few-shot examples, even when the target model cannot be accessed.
The paper addresses the problem of origin attribution for generated images, where the goal is to identify the model that generated a given image. The authors formulate this as a few-shot one-class classification task, where only a few images generated by a source model are available, and the source model cannot be accessed. To solve this task, the authors propose OCC-CLIP, a CLIP-based framework that enables the identification of an image's source model, even among multiple candidates. The key components are: Treating the few images from the source model as the target class, and randomly sampled images as the non-target class. Optimizing learnable prompts for the target and non-target classes, respectively. Employing an adversarial data augmentation (ADA) technique to extend the coverage of the non-target class space and better approximate the boundary to the target space. Extensive experiments on various generative models, including diffusion models and GANs, verify the effectiveness of the OCC-CLIP framework. The authors also demonstrate the applicability of their solution to a real-world commercial image generation system, DALL·E-3. The paper further explores the sensitivity of OCC-CLIP to factors such as the choice of source models, non-target datasets, number of shots, and image preprocessing. It also shows the effectiveness of OCC-CLIP in multi-source origin attribution scenarios.
Recent visual generative models can produce high-quality images, raising concerns about intellectual property protection and accountability for misuse. The authors formulate the origin attribution problem as a few-shot one-class classification task, where only a few images generated by a source model are available, and the source model cannot be accessed. Extensive experiments are conducted on 8 generative models, including diffusion models and GANs, as well as the recently released DALL·E-3 API.
"Recent progress in visual generative models enables the generation of high-quality images. To prevent the misuse of generated images, it is important to identify the origin model that generates them." "We aim to conduct origin attribution in a practical open-world setting (Fig. 1), where model parameters cannot be accessed and only a few samples generated by the model are available."

Deeper Inquiries

How can the OCC-CLIP framework be extended to handle more complex scenarios, such as when the target and non-target images have significant visual similarities?

In more complex scenarios where the target and non-target images have significant visual similarities, the OCC-CLIP framework can be extended by incorporating more advanced techniques to enhance the model's discriminative capabilities. Here are some strategies to address such scenarios: Feature Engineering: Introduce more sophisticated feature engineering methods to extract discriminative features from the images. This can involve using advanced image processing techniques or leveraging pre-trained models to extract high-level features that capture subtle differences between the target and non-target images. Ensemble Learning: Implement ensemble learning techniques to combine the outputs of multiple one-class classifiers trained on different feature representations or subsets of the data. By aggregating the predictions of multiple classifiers, the model can better handle scenarios with visual similarities between target and non-target images. Fine-tuning and Transfer Learning: Fine-tune the pre-trained CLIP model on a more diverse dataset that includes images with varying visual similarities. Transfer learning can help the model adapt to the specific characteristics of the target and non-target images in the more complex scenario. Adaptive Data Augmentation: Develop adaptive data augmentation strategies that dynamically adjust the augmentation techniques based on the visual similarities between the target and non-target images. This can help the model focus on the distinguishing features while minimizing the impact of shared visual characteristics. Advanced Adversarial Training: Enhance the adversarial data augmentation approach by incorporating more advanced adversarial training techniques, such as adversarial training with a stronger adversary or incorporating adversarial examples during training to improve the model's robustness to visually similar images.

How can the potential limitations of the adversarial data augmentation approach used in OCC-CLIP be further improved to enhance the model's robustness?

While adversarial data augmentation is a powerful technique, it also has some limitations that can be addressed to enhance the model's robustness: Gradient Masking: One limitation of adversarial data augmentation is gradient masking, where the model fails to learn meaningful gradients due to the presence of adversarial perturbations. To mitigate this, techniques like adversarial training with gradient penalty or incorporating regularization terms can be employed to ensure the model learns robust features. Mode Collapse: Adversarial data augmentation may suffer from mode collapse, where the model generates similar perturbations for different images, leading to a lack of diversity in the augmented data. To address this, techniques like diversity-promoting objectives or adaptive augmentation strategies can be implemented to encourage diverse perturbations. Adversarial Transferability: Adversarial perturbations generated for one model may not transfer well to another model, limiting the generalizability of the augmentation. To improve transferability, techniques like domain adaptation or model-agnostic perturbations can be explored to ensure the perturbations are effective across different models. Robustness Evaluation: Robustness evaluation techniques, such as adversarial testing or stress testing, can be employed to assess the model's resilience to adversarial perturbations and identify vulnerabilities that need to be addressed. Dynamic Augmentation: Implement dynamic augmentation strategies that adaptively adjust the strength and type of adversarial perturbations based on the model's performance and the complexity of the data. This can help optimize the augmentation process for improved robustness.

Given the growing importance of trustworthy AI systems, how could the insights from this work on origin attribution be applied to other domains beyond image generation, such as text or audio synthesis?

The insights from origin attribution in image generation can be applied to other domains like text or audio synthesis to enhance the trustworthiness of AI systems in the following ways: Authorship Verification: In text synthesis, the concept of origin attribution can be used for authorship verification to determine the source of generated text. By training one-class classifiers on text samples from known authors or sources, the model can verify the authenticity of generated text based on its similarity to the known sources. Plagiarism Detection: In educational or publishing settings, origin attribution techniques can be applied to detect plagiarism in generated text. By comparing the generated text with a database of original texts, the model can identify instances of plagiarism and ensure the integrity of the content. Voice Authentication: In audio synthesis, origin attribution can be utilized for voice authentication and verification. By training one-class classifiers on voice samples from authenticated users, the model can verify the identity of speakers based on the similarity of their generated audio to the known voice samples. Content Verification: In content generation tasks, such as generating news articles or audio transcripts, origin attribution can be used to verify the authenticity and source of the generated content. By attributing generated content to specific models or sources, the trustworthiness and reliability of the AI-generated content can be ensured. Cross-Modal Attribution: Extending the concept of origin attribution across different modalities, such as text, audio, and images, can enable comprehensive verification of multi-modal content generation systems. By integrating origin attribution techniques across modalities, the trustworthiness of AI systems that generate diverse types of content can be enhanced.