Conformal Prediction: A Flexible and Reliable Framework for Uncertainty Quantification in Natural Language Processing

Core Concepts

Conformal prediction is a promising framework for addressing the crucial need for uncertainty quantification in natural language processing, providing strong statistical guarantees while being model-agnostic and distribution-free.

Abstract

This paper provides a comprehensive survey of conformal prediction techniques and their applications in natural language processing (NLP). Conformal prediction (CP) is a flexible and reliable framework for uncertainty quantification that offers strong statistical guarantees with minimal assumptions.
The key highlights of the survey are:

Overview of conformal prediction: Definitions, ingredients, theoretical guarantees, and connections to hypothesis testing. CP is built on the notion of exchangeability and provides valid coverage probabilities for the prediction sets.

Extensions of conformal prediction: Handling conditional coverage, non-exchangeable data, and conformal risk control. These extensions address important challenges in applying CP to real-world NLP tasks.

Applications of conformal prediction in NLP:

Text classification and sequence tagging: CP provides reliable confidence estimates and can handle class imbalance and limited data.
Natural language generation: CP is used to mitigate hallucinations and provide calibrated uncertainty estimates at the sentence and token levels.
Uncertainty-based evaluation: CP can be used to assess the confidence of different NLP models and provide reliable quality estimation.
Faster inference: CP enables efficient model pruning and early exiting while preserving performance guarantees.

Future research directions: Exploring CP for human-computer interaction, handling label variation, achieving fairness, dealing with data limitations, and addressing open challenges in applying CP to NLP tasks.

The survey highlights the strong potential of conformal prediction to address the pressing need for reliable uncertainty quantification in NLP, and outlines promising avenues for future research and development.

Stats

None.

Quotes

None.

Key Insights Distilled From

Conformal Prediction for Natural Language Processing: A Survey

by Marg... at arxiv.org 05-06-2024

https://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01976.pdf

Deeper Inquiries

How can conformal prediction be extended to handle the conditional and recursive nature of language generation tasks more effectively?

Conformal prediction can be extended to handle the conditional and recursive nature of language generation tasks more effectively by incorporating Mondrian conformal predictors. Mondrian conformal predictors provide coverage guarantees over different data categories, such as partitions of the data by label or by a specific feature. In the context of language generation, this approach can be adapted to compute quantiles or p-values within each class or category, ensuring that the prediction sets are tailored to the specific characteristics of the data. By leveraging Mondrian conformal predictors, language generation models can generate prediction sets that account for the conditional and recursive nature of the task, providing more accurate and reliable outputs.

How can conformal prediction be used to identify and mitigate biases in NLP systems in a principled manner?

Conformal prediction can be used to identify and mitigate biases in NLP systems in a principled manner by incorporating equalized conformal prediction techniques. Equalized conformal prediction methods distribute coverage evenly across protected attributes, helping to reduce biases and unfairness in model predictions. By applying equalized conformal prediction, NLP systems can ensure that the prediction sets are balanced and unbiased across different demographic or categorical groups. Additionally, conformal prediction can be used to quantify uncertainty in model predictions, allowing for a more transparent assessment of biases and enabling the development of strategies to mitigate them effectively.

What are the potential synergies between conformal prediction and other uncertainty quantification techniques, such as Bayesian methods, that could lead to more robust and reliable NLP systems?

The potential synergies between conformal prediction and Bayesian methods in uncertainty quantification can lead to more robust and reliable NLP systems. By combining the strengths of both approaches, NLP systems can benefit from improved calibration, coverage guarantees, and uncertainty quantification. Bayesian methods provide a principled framework for modeling uncertainty through probabilistic inference, while conformal prediction offers non-parametric and distribution-free guarantees for prediction sets.
One potential synergy is to use Bayesian methods to estimate the uncertainty in the non-conformity scores used in conformal prediction. By incorporating Bayesian uncertainty estimates into the conformal prediction framework, NLP systems can achieve more accurate and reliable prediction sets. Additionally, the combination of Bayesian methods and conformal prediction can enhance the overall uncertainty quantification process, leading to more robust and trustworthy NLP systems that can provide reliable confidence information and mitigate risks such as hallucinations and biases.