Impact of Spatial Auditory Navigation on User Experience in Augmented Outdoor Navigation Tasks

Khái niệm cốt lõi

Spatial auditory navigation can enhance user experience during augmented outdoor navigation tasks by providing additional sensory cues that complement or replace visual information, leading to improved realism, contextualization, immersion, and accessibility.

Tóm tắt

This study explores the impact of spatial auditory navigation on user experience during augmented outdoor navigation tasks. The researchers designed a mobile AR application to guide tourists to various statues in Tiergarten, Berlin, using two navigation modalities: spatial auditory navigation and augmented visual navigation.
The key findings are:

Spatial auditory navigation performed significantly better than augmented visual navigation in terms of Hedonic Quality, indicating that it was more exciting, engaging, and inventive for users.

While spatial auditory navigation scored lower on Pragmatic Quality compared to augmented visual navigation, the difference was not statistically significant, suggesting that it may be less efficient in providing precise distance, orientation, and direction information.

Overall, the spatial auditory navigation condition received a higher UEQ-Overall score, which was above average compared to the benchmark, while the augmented visual navigation was below average.

The results suggest that spatial auditory navigation can enhance the user experience in augmented outdoor navigation tasks by providing additional sensory cues that complement visual information, leading to improved realism, contextualization, immersion, and accessibility. However, further research is needed to confirm these findings and explore ways to optimize the balance between Hedonic and Pragmatic Quality in spatial auditory navigation for outdoor AR applications.

Thống kê

The average Affinity for Technology Interaction of the participants was 3.86 (SD = 0.75).
Spatial auditory navigation (M = 1.750; SD = 1.058) performed significantly better (t (19) = 2.983; p = 0.008) than augmented visual navigation (M = 0.725; SD = 1.292) on Hedonic Quality score.
Spatial auditory navigation (M = 0.613; SD = 1.163) performed lower than augmented visual navigation (M = 1.225; SD = 1.405) on Pragmatic Quality score, but the results did not reach statistical significance (t (19) = 2.983; p = 0.089).
The spatial auditory navigation (M = 1.183; SD = 0.909) performed better than augmented visual navigation (M = 0.976; SD = 1.122) on UEQ-Overall, but the difference was not statistically significant (t (19) = 0.801; p = 0.433).

Trích dẫn

"Spatial auditory navigation may improve the user experience in augmented outdoor navigation activities by delivering extra sensory signals that complement or replace visual clues."
"Spatial audio is important in AR because it delivers a more realistic auditory experience, contextual information, immersion, and accessibility."

Thông tin chi tiết chính được chắt lọc từ

Impact of spatial auditory navigation on user experience during augmented outdoor navigation tasks

by Jan-Niklas V... lúc arxiv.org 04-26-2024

https://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16473.pdf

Yêu cầu sâu hơn

How can the balance between Hedonic and Pragmatic Quality be optimized in spatial auditory navigation for outdoor AR applications?

In order to optimize the balance between Hedonic and Pragmatic Quality in spatial auditory navigation for outdoor AR applications, several strategies can be implemented. Firstly, enhancing the novelty and engagement of the spatial auditory cues can contribute to a higher Hedonic Quality. This can be achieved by incorporating dynamic and immersive soundscapes that captivate users' attention and create a sense of excitement. Additionally, providing clear and accurate spatial audio cues that effectively guide users towards their destinations can improve the Pragmatic Quality. Ensuring that the spatial auditory navigation system is reliable, precise, and user-friendly will enhance the overall user experience and satisfaction.

What are the potential limitations or drawbacks of relying solely on spatial auditory navigation for outdoor navigation tasks, and how can they be addressed?

Relying solely on spatial auditory navigation for outdoor navigation tasks may have some limitations and drawbacks. One potential limitation is the accuracy and precision of spatial audio cues, which may not always provide users with the exact location or direction needed for navigation. This can lead to confusion and inefficiency in reaching the desired destination. Moreover, environmental factors such as background noise or interference can affect the clarity and effectiveness of spatial auditory cues. To address these limitations, integrating backup systems or alternative modalities, such as visual cues or haptic feedback, can provide users with additional information and support to supplement spatial auditory navigation. This multi-modal approach can enhance the reliability and robustness of the navigation system in outdoor environments.

How might the integration of spatial auditory navigation with other modalities, such as haptic feedback or augmented visual cues, further enhance the user experience in outdoor AR environments?

Integrating spatial auditory navigation with other modalities, such as haptic feedback or augmented visual cues, can significantly enhance the user experience in outdoor AR environments. By combining spatial auditory cues with haptic feedback, users can receive tactile sensations that complement the auditory information, providing a multi-sensory experience that improves spatial awareness and navigation accuracy. Additionally, augmented visual cues can offer users visual references and landmarks that enhance the overall understanding of the environment and aid in navigation. This integration of multiple modalities creates a more comprehensive and immersive experience, catering to different user preferences and enhancing accessibility for individuals with varying sensory abilities. Overall, the synergy of spatial auditory navigation with haptic feedback and augmented visual cues can optimize user engagement, navigation efficiency, and overall satisfaction in outdoor AR environments.